Just One Year (Just One Day #2) – Gayle Forman

Just One Year (Just One Day #2) – Gayle FormanTitle: Just One Year (Just One Day #2) by Gayle Forman
Publishing Info: October 10, 2013 by Penguin
Source: Anderson's Bookshop
Genres: New Adult, Young Adult, Contemporary
Find it on the web: Buy from Amazon // Goodreads
Date Completed: October 5, 2013
Related Posts: If I Stay (If I Stay #1), Where She Went (If I Stay #2), Just One Day (Just One Day #1), Sisters in Sanity, If I Stay (If I Stay #1), Where She Went (If I Stay #2), Just One Day (Just One Day #1), Just One Night (Just One Day #2.5), I Was Here, Leave Me

Just One Day. Just One Year. Just One Read. Before you find out how their story ends, remember how it began.... When he opens his eyes, Willem doesn’t know where in the world he is—Prague or Dubrovnik or back in Amsterdam. All he knows is that he is once again alone, and that he needs to find a girl named Lulu. They shared one magical day in Paris, and something about that day—that girl—makes Willem wonder if they aren’t fated to be together. He travels all over the world, from Mexico to India, hoping to reconnect with her. But as months go by and Lulu remains elusive, Willem starts to question if the hand of fate is as strong as he’d thought. . . . The romantic, emotional companion to Just One Day, this is a story of the choices we make and the accidents that happen—and the happiness we can find when the two intersect.

bookreview1

** Caution: If you have not read JUST ONE DAY yet, there will be spoilers for that story. This review for JUST ONE YEAR is as spoiler-free as I can make it and I reveal no SPECIFIC details but there are some strong feels so if you haven’t read the book yet, just beware! **

JUST ONE YEAR was a very different read for me than JUST ONE DAY and I really contribute that to the fact that it felt much more like a personal journey and much more of a personal struggle for Willem than it had been reading Allyson’s story. I feel like the reason for that was that Allyson was going through so many transitions at once — from high school to college, from Europe to home, from sheltered to wanderer — whereas Willem, although already a constant traveler, felt much more stuck in his life. He seemed much more lost, unsure of where to go and what to do and was already in the thick of it when he met Allyson. Allyson hadn’t realized her life needed a change UNTIL she met Willem so for her, I felt much more of the romantic attachment — especially since her story changes with the encounter with Willem and Willem’s story starts after his meeting with Allyson had already come and gone.

Of course I had been dying to hear Willem’s side of the story ever since JUST ONE DAY, and I found it really fascinating. Willem’s story sort of unfolded much more like a mystery to me. We slowly got to find out the secrets of his past that had shaped his life as well as the way he interacted with Allyson (and the various girls he met in Paris). I really, really appreciated getting to know Willem more and finding out about his family. We knew nothing of his parents except their names in JOD and it was so bittersweet to learn about his relationship with both of them and exactly where that relationship stood at the beginning of JUST ONE YEAR, not to mention how his relationship changed towards the conclusion of the book as well.

JUST ONE YEAR wasn’t as emotionally moving or particularly as life-changing as JUST ONE DAY had been simply because it was an entirely different journey that we were on. Of course I had identified with Allyson as the “good girl”, aiming to please her parents and please others so I just connected more with her journey on a personal level than I had with Willem — But that’s not to say that I didn’t feel for Willem because I really did feel his pain, his loneliness, his sense of just feeling a little lost and I appreciated the changes he went through as well.

The biggest thing that struck me about JUST ONE YEAR were all those “almost”s — all the “missed connections” — and that absolutely killed me. Just to see how close he and Allyson came to crossing paths — the attempts to find each other and the pure chances were incredibly surprising! But as we know from Allyson’s side of the book, they never do end up meeting until her story in JUST ONE DAY concludes, leaving us with Allyson at Willem’s front door. To watch all of Willem’s attempts to find her or run into her, though, just was so heartbreaking. She really had an impact on him and even though I knew they wouldn’t meet up again until that moment, I secretly kept hoping for there to be a chance meeting!

 ** Strong feels ahead about the ending of this book that may be spoilery if you haven’t finished this book yet! Just a kind word of warning 🙂 **

So the ending. We already know that the end of JUST ONE DAY ends with Allyson at Willem’s door step but we don’t know where it goes from there and it takes us a while to get back to that point because obviously we have to find out Willem’s side of what happened after he and Allyson separated in Paris. I won’t say exactly HOW the book ends, but I cannot write this review and omit the fact at how disappointed I was with it. I want to say I can understand Gayle’s choice to end the book like this… But I really can’t. (Spoilers on the specifics of the ending below… Do not click if you haven’t read the book.)

View Spoiler »

After finishing the book and ending the way it did… I was honestly enraged. I felt let down. Abandoned in the middle of this story. And I HATED that I was mad. I really enjoyed the whole book up until that point and I couldn’t believe it ended like that. I legitimately felt a little bit betrayed that I had been so emotionally invested in the ending for these two characters and that was the way we left them. I may have been spoiled by how perfectly WHERE SHE WENT ended because I absolutely loved that whole book, cover to cover, but I didn’t quite understand why JUST ONE YEAR had to end like that.

I wanted this to be a series I could rave about, shove in the hands of friends, jump up and down with, hug!!!! But the ending left me feeling so confused and emotionally raw — I had a serious book hangover, but not quite in a good way. I thought about this for HOURS after I finished reading and my feelings have settled a little bit, but I’m still upset with the way this book ended and I can’t deny that if affected how I feel about this book as a whole. I will still recommend the read but just a word of warning to the readers that you may be in for shock and rage in the last chapter.

character_breakdown1

Willem de Ruiter // Character Obsessions: Finding Lulu, traveling, trying to make connections, acting.
Willem was an interesting character to follow throughout JUST ONE YEAR. I actually really liked getting to know him more and seeing all of the secrets — or simply things he didn’t outright say — that Allyson had missed. I appreciated his character so much more and he really came to life more. I think he was flawed, but his run in and day in Paris with Allyson set him on a new course to realize that maybe he had been stuck in a rut and she turned him on to parts of himself he didn’t know were buried so deep in his soul. There really were kind of soul mates — not just romantically — but that they each brought out a new, better side of each other.

I kind of don’t even want to talk about other characters because Willem is such a vagabond and such an transient character that he doesn’t stay in one place — physically or emotionally — long enough for these people to make lasting impressions. Oh, they do make lasting impressions, mentally and emotionally, but their physical presence isn’t as prominent in Willem’s life and he doesn’t always realize the impact these people have, sometimes not until they are long gone from his life.
addiction_factor1

Kept Me Hooked On: Fate. There’s a serious question about fate, chances, and intentions in JUST ONE YEAR and how much is really and truly left up to chance. I really enjoyed seeing Willem figure out what he needed to leave up to fate and what was impacted directly by his choices and intentional decisions.
Left Me Wanting More: Of an ending. I think after that review, it goes without saying. Sorry, Gayle.

Addiction Rating
Read it.

I can’t NOT suggest you read this — If you’ve read JUST ONE DAY, you need to see how things happen in JUST ONE YEAR, but just be prepared for a bit of a shock of an ending, I suppose. I know lots of people who totally and completely loved it and weren’t fazed by the ending at all. I know of others who were totally shocked and so disappointed that it ruined the entire experience for them. I think it’s a necessary read to finish out the duo of books and if you’ve got a copy of JUST ONE DAY, you probably need it to finish out your book collection anyway, amirite?

book_recommendations1

BOOKS LIKE JUST ONE YEAR

(Click the cover to see my review!)

          The Beginning of Everything     Meant to Be

5 thoughts on “Just One Year (Just One Day #2) – Gayle Forman

  1. Maggie @ Just a Couple More Pages

    I think I commented on your Goodreads status about this, but yeah, I was definitely surprised by the ending. I wasn’t as upset as you were, but I still felt like Gayle Forman sold us short. But, the more time I’ve had to think about it, the more I think that’s pretty much the only way to end the story. To me the perfect thing would be to have the two books they way they are and then a third book that picks up maybe a couple years later and establishes how Willem and Allyson made (or didn’t make) their relationship work.

    1. Brittany Post author

      I definitely would have been up for a third book! BUT, I also feel like…… what would happen? The suspense and excitement of building up the romance is gone now, although we could just have a nice story of Willem and Allyson…. Hahaha we’re plotting this book for Gayle Forman apparently 🙂

  2. Nicole

    So it seems many felt the way that you did. Loved Willem’s story but felt let down by the ending. And I picked up this book expecting to feel the same based on the hints I had gotten. But (and this might change when I write my review and really think on it) I think I feel the opposite…? I did really like to learn more about Willem’s past and his family and how that had shaped who he had become. I like how Allison had such an impact on him and their interaction kind of pushed him to change and grow. But I didn’t relate to him as well as I related to Allison and I wasn’t as invested in his story. I can still really appreciate it though. As for that ending – I think I actually really like it. I know its the same as Just One Day and kills us readers a little bit but in JOD we had no idea how Willem was feeling so there was so much uncertainty. But now we know how much he missed Allison and Gayle Forman leaves no doubt that it’s the start of something beautiful. I’m surprised I liked it, truthfully. I understand your sentiments. I guess I find it kind of romantic and since I know they will be together, that’s really all I wanted! This is a great review as always Brittany!! 😀

    1. Brittany Post author

      Thank you for the novel comment! Okay, replying… *takes deep breath* and go!
      I actually really loved reading Willem’s story too. I think we learned so much about him that explains so much about his relationship with Allyson and how they ended up changing each other’s lives in ways they never expected.
      I think I wasn’t AS invested in his story either, but probably because Just One Day was like, my life. I connected with Allyson in so many ways and I had been in her shoes (or variations there of) so many times that that book just GOT ME. With Willem, I was more anxious to get him back together with Allyson because I needed to know her reaction to everything that happened and I wanted to get back to where we left off with her. I think that was something really important to me and I didn’t realize how important it was until I didn’t have that.
      I think now that time has passed since I finished (and wrote the review), I’m coming around to it more and I feel better about the ending and why Gayle Forman chose to end it that way, but it just didn’t give me the warm fuzzies and the butterflies like Just One Day did and I just wanted to wrap it up with more FEELINGS. I just needed like, one more sentence to help me out but I just didn’t quite get it.

      Thank you so much for the wonderful comment! I needed to TALK about this book haha!

  3. Alexa Y.

    I am getting ever more curious about this book the more I hear about it! I’m definitely excited to get to know Willem a little better, and to try to understand his side of the story. But I’m not looking forward to the ending (which I didn’t read about in your review, but can see that you have strong feelings about). I hope it turns out to be a good reading experience for me!

Comments are closed.